REALITYWIPE

RESEARCHERS

The Science of New-Manager Scripts: Why the Player-to-Coach Transition Breaks Smart People

3 the researchers behind it — "I just need to get my team performing" and "everyone has to like me before I can lead them" feel like practical managerial wisdom. Organizational sci

Harvard Business School

Linda A. Hill

Known for:Longitudinal research on the new-manager transition — documenting the identity crisis, role misconceptions, and cognitive shifts required in the first year of management

Key findings

  1. 2007

    Across 19 managers tracked through their first year, Hill found the central challenge was not skill acquisition but identity transformation — new managers must shift their definition of success from personal achievement to enabling others, and must abandon the individual-contributor mental scripts that got them promoted. ↗

  2. 2007

    Hill documents three core misconceptions first-year managers carry: that formal authority gives them power (it gives them accountability), that being liked is a prerequisite for leadership (it produces only surface compliance), and that their role is still to do great individual work (it is to develop others who do the work). ↗

Harvard Business School

Nicole Abi-Esber

Known for:Research on the feedback gap — why people systematically underestimate how much others want candid feedback, and how this perception error drives widespread under-delivery of useful performance information

Key findings

  1. 2022

    Across multiple experiments, Abi-Esber, Abel, Folke, and Gino found that people giving feedback significantly underestimated how much recipients wanted candid input — especially positive feedback — and overestimated how uncomfortable recipients would feel, creating a systematic bias toward silence. ↗

University of Virginia Darden School of Business

James R. Detert

Known for:Research on implicit voice theories — the pre-formed beliefs about whether speaking up to authority is safe or useful, which act as automatic filters that suppress voice before employees even reach the moment of decision

Key findings

  1. 2011

    With Edmondson, Detert found that workers' decisions to voice or stay silent are often made before they reach the conversation, driven by implicit voice theories — internalized schemas about when speaking up to authority is safe, useful, or appropriate — acting as automatic pre-filters on the decision to speak. ↗

View full research file ↗All researchers