BY_THE_NUMBERS

The Science of Envy: Why the Emotion That Stings Can Also Push You Forward

Envy has a reputation as a purely destructive emotion — the one that makes you want to tear others down rather than build yourself up. But decades of social psychology research tell a more precise story. Envy is not one thing. Research distinguishes benign envy, which motivates upward striving, from malicious envy, which motivates pulling the other person down — and the deciding factor between the two is perceived deservingness. When a friend gets something you want and you believe they earned it, the envy that follows tends to be benign: it predicts warmer, more supportive behavior toward them, not less. The old script — 'envy is always a character flaw' — misses this split almost entirely.

2 typesof envy identified by van de Ven, Zeelenberg and Pieters (2009): benign envy that motivates moving oneself up, and malicious envy that motivates pulling the other down — split by perceived deservingness key factorperceived deservingness — whether the envied person is seen as having earned their advantage — is the single reported mechanism that tips envy from malicious to benign, across multiple experimental paradigms less maliceobservers experience less malicious envy toward successful peers who reveal past failures — Harvard Business School (2018) finding showing that humanizing success shifts which form of envy gets triggered self-controldispositional self-control moderates which form of envy emerges — higher self-control predicts channeling envy toward the benign motivational form rather than the malicious destructive one, per the 2021 Frontiers in Psychology validation study

View full research file ↗test your knowledge →All research