The Science of Freelance Income Anxiety: Why the Swings Hurt More Than the Total

TEST_YOURSELF · How well do you know this science?

1. 01 According to Prause, Dooley, and Huh's national longitudinal study, what actually predicts depression in income research — the level of income, or something else?

   Only how low the average income isOnly whether someone is self-employedThe volatility of the income itself, independent of its average levelWhether someone has a college degree

   Prause, Dooley, and Huh (2009) found income volatility predicted depression even after controlling for how much people actually earned and their prior mental health — the swings themselves are the risk factor. source ↗

2. 02 In the U.S. Financial Diaries research, what mainly drove families' income spikes and dips?

   Losing or changing jobsNormal month-to-month swings within the same ongoing workDivorce or family breakupMoving to a new city

   Hannagan and Morduch (2015) found households averaged 2.7 income spikes and 2.7 dips a year, each roughly half a typical month's income, with job loss explaining almost none of it. source ↗

3. 03 The 2018 study 'Women (Still) Ask For Less' analyzed over 48,000 freelancer profiles on a major platform. What did it find?

   Men and women set identical hourly ratesThe platform's algorithm set lower rates for womenThe median woman's self-set rate was about three-quarters of the median man'sWomen earned more overall despite lower rates

   Foong, Vincent, Hecht, and Gerber (2018) found the median woman's self-set hourly rate was 74% of the median man's for comparable work, on a platform where freelancers — not employers — choose their own listed rate. source ↗

4. 04 Patel and Rietveld's 2020 study found self-employed workers had more short-term psychological distress than wage workers during the early pandemic. What explained the gap?

   Self-employed people are naturally more anxiousFeelings of financial insecurity and job-loss risk mediated the differenceSelf-employed people work more hoursThere was no meaningful gap once other factors were controlled

   Patel and Rietveld (2020) found the extra distress among the self-employed was mediated by self-reported financial insecurity and perceived risk of losing income — not by self-employment status alone. source ↗

5. 05 A 2023 study directly compared self-esteem between freelancers and people in traditional careers. What did it find?

   Freelancers scored lower on self-esteem measuresThere was no measurable differenceFreelancers scored higher on self-esteem and self-confidence measuresSelf-esteem couldn't be measured across the two groups

   Umlauft (2023) found freelancers scored higher, not lower, on global self-attitude, self-esteem, and self-confidence measures compared to people in traditional careers — undercutting 'just be more confident' as an explanation for underpricing. source ↗